← back to the ledger
Open

XLE · Bull Call Spread

opened Sep 4, 2026, 05:23 PM UTC expiry 2026-09-11 jrn_20260904T172239Z_dec5bca73 openai:gpt-5.6-sol | anthropic:claude-opus-5 | openai:gpt-5
The thesis

XLE should finish between $64 and $67 on September 11 as crude near $90 and ongoing U.S.-Iran/Hormuz risk support energy equities, while the sector's recent 12.8% monthly rally limits further upside.

Resolves2026-09-11
Band 64–67
Expected drift+1.4%
Fact — contract arithmetic

Payoff at expiry

BE 64.68entry 64.125546576$9,372.00$0−$4,828.00
Max loss$4,828.00
Max profit $9,372.00
Breakeven 64.68
Not yet attributed

This position hasn't reached its thesis horizon, or the thesis had no checkable condition — attribution only fires once resolution is possible.

The thesis

Claim: XLE should finish between $64 and $67 on September 11 as crude near $90 and ongoing U.S.-Iran/Hormuz risk support energy equities, while the sector's recent 12.8% monthly rally limits further upside.

Resolves: 2026-09-11, band [64.0, 67.0]

Expected drift: +1.4%

Vol view: 18.0% annualized realized

From $64.13, XLE should finish between $64 and $67 on September 11 as crude near $90 and continuing U.S.-Iran/Hormuz risk support energy equities, while the sector's recent rally caps upside. A trade below $63 invalidates the support thesis.

Why this trade

Submitted one paper-trade action:

  • XLE Sep 11 $64/$66 bull call spread
  • Quantity: 71
  • Limit debit: $0.68
  • Status: Pending, 0 filled
  • Maximum debit risk: approximately $4,828
  • Thesis: Crude near $90 and U.S.–Iran/Hormuz risk support XLE, targeting $64–$67 by September 11.
  • Estimated edge: 58% modeled probability of profit; +$23 EV per spread after costs under the stated view.
  • Exit rules recorded: −50% premium stop, +60% profit target, one-day time stop, underlying invalidation below $63.

The $63 underlying stop is too low to limit spread losses materially; the premium stop remains the effective loss control. A 15%–21% realized-volatility forecast through September 11 was also recorded at 54% confidence.

Structures considered

structure entry cost max profit max loss payoff ratio
XLE 64/66 bull call spread $67.00 $133.00 $-67.00 1.34 chosen
XLE 63.5/65/67 broken-wing call butterfly $34.00 $116.00 $-84.00 0.86

Sources

  • idleinbox/pos_20260904T172239Z_idle_f394fc9d

Position details

Legs

side qty symbol
buy 71 XLE260911C00064000
sell 71 XLE260911C00066000

Exit rules

rule detail
stop_loss basis position_mark, threshold -50.0%
profit_target basis position_mark, threshold 60.0%
time_stop days_before_expiry 1
underlying_stop direction below, level 63.0

Outcome

Open - this section fills in when the position resolves.